0.07/0.13 % Problem : theBenchmark.p : TPTP v0.0.0. Released v0.0.0. 0.07/0.13 % Command : vampire_hol --schedule thf_2019 --mode portfolio --time_limit %ds %s 0.13/0.32 % Computer : n017.cluster.edu 0.13/0.32 % Model : x86_64 x86_64 0.13/0.32 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz 0.13/0.32 % Memory : 8042.1875MB 0.13/0.32 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64 0.13/0.32 % CPULimit : 180 0.13/0.32 % DateTime : Thu Aug 29 13:20:49 EDT 2019 0.13/0.33 % CPUTime : 0.17/0.40 % lrs-3_4:1_cunif=on:en=on:foolp=on:holcelim=on:holscev=on:combelim=inference_rules:afea=on:afp=1000:afq=1.4:amm=sco:fde=none:gs=on:lcm=reverse:lma=on:nwc=1.5:stl=30:sd=1:ss=axioms:sp=reverse_arity:urr=on:updr=off:uhcvi=on_11 on theBenchmark 1.53/1.70 % Time limit reached! 1.53/1.70 % ------------------------------ 1.53/1.70 % Version: Vampire 4.2.2 (commit 9d3eacc on 2019-04-30 12:01:32 +0100) 1.53/1.70 % Termination reason: Time limit 1.53/1.70 % Termination phase: Saturation 1.53/1.70 1.53/1.70 % Memory used [KB]: 50916 1.53/1.70 % Time elapsed: 1.300 s 1.53/1.70 % ------------------------------ 1.53/1.70 % ------------------------------ 1.53/1.73 % lrs+1011_5:4_anc=none:bsr=on:ccuc=small_ones:irw=on:stl=300d:fde=unused:holscev=on:sp=reverse_arity:sos=on:foolp=on:acc=on:afp=10000:gs=on:nwc=1.2:holcelim=on:updr=off:sac=on:afea=on:newcnf=on:gsem=off:cond=on:add=large:en=on:combelim=inference_rules:gsaa=from_current:amm=off:nm=2:afq=2:cunif=on_38 on theBenchmark 5.58/5.73 % Time limit reached! 5.58/5.73 % ------------------------------ 5.58/5.73 % Version: Vampire 4.2.2 (commit 9d3eacc on 2019-04-30 12:01:32 +0100) 5.58/5.73 % Termination reason: Time limit 5.58/5.73 % Termination phase: Saturation 5.58/5.73 5.58/5.73 % Memory used [KB]: 94667 5.58/5.73 % Time elapsed: 4.0000 s 5.58/5.73 % ------------------------------ 5.58/5.73 % ------------------------------ 5.58/5.76 % ott+11_16_cunif=on:en=on:foolp=on:holcelim=on:holscev=on:combelim=inference_rules:afea=on:av=off:gs=on:gsem=on:irw=on:lma=on:nm=64:newcnf=on:nwc=1.3:sas=z3:sp=reverse_arity_16 on theBenchmark 7.42/7.56 % Time limit reached! 7.42/7.56 % ------------------------------ 7.42/7.56 % Version: Vampire 4.2.2 (commit 9d3eacc on 2019-04-30 12:01:32 +0100) 7.42/7.56 % Termination reason: Time limit 7.42/7.56 % Termination phase: Saturation 7.42/7.56 7.42/7.56 % Memory used [KB]: 41705 7.42/7.56 % Time elapsed: 1.800 s 7.42/7.56 % ------------------------------ 7.42/7.56 % ------------------------------ 7.51/7.59 % lrs+1011_7_anc=none:stl=300d:holscev=on:sp=reverse_arity:foolp=on:lma=on:urr=on:afp=40000:nwc=2.5:holcelim=on:flr=on:updr=off:afea=on:cond=on:add=large:en=on:combelim=both:amm=off:nm=4:fsr=off:afq=1.4:afr=on:er=known:cunif=on_2 on theBenchmark 7.97/8.09 % Time limit reached! 7.97/8.09 % ------------------------------ 7.97/8.09 % Version: Vampire 4.2.2 (commit 9d3eacc on 2019-04-30 12:01:32 +0100) 7.97/8.09 % Termination reason: Time limit 7.97/8.09 % Termination phase: Saturation 7.97/8.09 7.97/8.09 % Memory used [KB]: 27121 7.97/8.09 % Time elapsed: 0.500 s 7.97/8.09 % ------------------------------ 7.97/8.09 % ------------------------------ 7.97/8.11 % ott+11_16_sas=z3:irw=on:e2e=off:holscev=on:sp=reverse_arity:foolp=on:addc=user:lma=on:gs=on:nwc=1.3:holcelim=on:afea=on:newcnf=on:gsem=on:en=on:combelim=inference_rules:nm=64:av=off_16 on theBenchmark 9.86/9.92 % Time limit reached! 9.86/9.92 % ------------------------------ 9.86/9.92 % Version: Vampire 4.2.2 (commit 9d3eacc on 2019-04-30 12:01:32 +0100) 9.86/9.92 % Termination reason: Time limit 9.86/9.92 % Termination phase: Saturation 9.86/9.92 9.86/9.92 % Memory used [KB]: 40809 9.86/9.92 % Time elapsed: 1.800 s 9.86/9.92 % ------------------------------ 9.86/9.92 % ------------------------------ 9.86/9.94 % lrs+1011_7_anc=none:stl=300d:holscev=on:foolp=on:lma=on:afp=4000:nwc=2.5:holcelim=on:updr=off:afea=on:cond=on:add=large:combelim=inference_rules:amm=off:bd=off:nm=4:fsr=off:csl=3:afq=1.4:afr=on:er=known_2 on theBenchmark 9.89/10.05 % Refutation found. Thanks to Tanya! 9.89/10.05 % SZS status Theorem for theBenchmark 9.89/10.05 % SZS output start Proof for theBenchmark 9.89/10.05 89. (subsetTrans = ! [X3,X4,X5] : (((subset @ X3) @ X4) => (((subset @ X4) @ X5) => ((subset @ X3) @ X5)))) [input] 9.89/10.05 92. (subset2powerset = ! [X3,X4] : (((subset @ X3) @ X4) => ((in @ X3) @ (powerset @ X4)))) [input] 9.89/10.05 96. (powersetE1 = ! [X3,X4] : (((in @ X4) @ (powerset @ X3)) => ((subset @ X4) @ X3))) [input] 9.89/10.05 111. (binintersectLsub = ! [X3,X4] : ((subset @ ((binintersect @ X3) @ X4)) @ X3)) [input] 9.89/10.05 231. setextAx => (emptysetAx => (setadjoinAx => (powersetAx => (setunionAx => (omega0Ax => (omegaSAx => (omegaIndAx => (replAx => (foundationAx => (wellorderingAx => (descrp => (dsetconstrI => (dsetconstrEL => (dsetconstrER => (exuE1 => (prop2setE => (emptysetE => (emptysetimpfalse => (notinemptyset => (exuE3e => (setext => (emptyI => (noeltsimpempty => (setbeta => (nonemptyE1 => (nonemptyI => (nonemptyI1 => (setadjoinIL => (emptyinunitempty => (setadjoinIR => (setadjoinE => (setadjoinOr => (setoftrueEq => (powersetI => (emptyinPowerset => (emptyInPowerset => (powersetE => (setunionI => (setunionE => (subPowSU => (exuE2 => (nonemptyImpWitness => (uniqinunit => (notinsingleton => (eqinunit => (singletonsswitch => (upairsetE => (upairsetIL => (upairsetIR => (emptyE1 => (vacuousDall => (quantDeMorgan1 => (quantDeMorgan2 => (quantDeMorgan3 => (quantDeMorgan4 => (prop2setI => (prop2set2propI => (notdexE => (notdallE => (exuI1 => (exuI3 => (exuI2 => (inCongP => (in__Cong => (exuE3u => (exu__Cong => (emptyset__Cong => (setadjoin__Cong => (powerset__Cong => (setunion__Cong => (omega__Cong => (exuEu => (descr__Cong => (dsetconstr__Cong => (subsetI1 => (eqimpsubset2 => (eqimpsubset1 => (subsetI2 => (emptysetsubset => (subsetE => (subsetE2 => (notsubsetI => (notequalI1 => (notequalI2 => (subsetRefl => (subsetTrans => (setadjoinSub => (setadjoinSub2 => (subset2powerset => (setextsub => (subsetemptysetimpeq => (powersetI1 => (powersetE1 => (inPowerset => (powersetsubset => (sepInPowerset => (sepSubset => (binunionIL => (upairset2IR => (binunionIR => (binunionEcases => (binunionE => (binunionLsub => (binunionRsub => (binintersectI => (binintersectSubset5 => (binintersectEL => (binintersectLsub => (binintersectSubset2 => (binintersectSubset3 => (binintersectER => (disjointsetsI1 => (binintersectRsub => (binintersectSubset4 => (binintersectSubset1 => (bs114d => (setminusI => (setminusEL => (setminusER => (setminusSubset2 => (setminusERneg => (setminusELneg => (setminusILneg => (setminusIRneg => (setminusLsub => (setminusSubset1 => (symdiffE => (symdiffI1 => (symdiffI2 => (symdiffIneg1 => (symdiffIneg2 => (secondinupair => (setukpairIL => (setukpairIR => (kpairiskpair => (kpairp => (singletonsubset => (singletoninpowerset => (singletoninpowunion => (upairset2E => (upairsubunion => (upairinpowunion => (ubforcartprodlem1 => (ubforcartprodlem2 => (ubforcartprodlem3 => (cartprodpairin => (cartprodmempair1 => (cartprodmempair => (setunionE2 => (setunionsingleton1 => (setunionsingleton2 => (setunionsingleton => (singletonprop => (ex1E1 => (ex1I => (ex1I2 => (singletonsuniq => (setukpairinjL1 => (kfstsingleton => (theprop => (kfstpairEq => (cartprodfstin => (setukpairinjL2 => (setukpairinjL => (setukpairinjR11 => (setukpairinjR12 => (setukpairinjR1 => (upairequniteq => (setukpairinjR2 => (setukpairinjR => (ksndsingleton => (ksndpairEq => (kpairsurjEq => (cartprodsndin => (cartprodpairmemEL => (cartprodpairmemER => (cartprodmempaircEq => (cartprodfstpairEq => (cartprodsndpairEq => (cartprodpairsurjEq => (dpsetconstrI => (dpsetconstrSub => (setOfPairsIsBReln => (dpsetconstrERa => (dpsetconstrEL1 => (dpsetconstrEL2 => (dpsetconstrER => (funcImageSingleton => (apProp => (app => (infuncsetfunc => (ap2p => (funcinfuncset => (lamProp => (lamp => (lam2p => (brelnall1 => (brelnall2 => (ex1E2 => (funcGraphProp1 => (funcGraphProp3 => (funcGraphProp2 => (funcextLem => (funcGraphProp4 => (subbreln => (eqbreln => (funcext => (funcext2 => (ap2apEq1 => (ap2apEq2 => (beta1 => (eta1 => (lam2lamEq => (beta2 => (eta2 => (iffalseProp1 => (iffalseProp2 => (iftrueProp1 => (iftrueProp2 => (ifSingleton => (ifp => (theeq => (iftrue => (iffalse => (iftrueorfalse => ! [X3,X11] : (((in @ X11) @ (powerset @ X3)) => ! [X16] : (((in @ X16) @ (powerset @ X3)) => ((in @ ((binintersect @ X11) @ X16)) @ (powerset @ X3))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) [input] 9.89/10.05 232. ~(setextAx => (emptysetAx => (setadjoinAx => (powersetAx => (setunionAx => (omega0Ax => (omegaSAx => (omegaIndAx => (replAx => (foundationAx => (wellorderingAx => (descrp => (dsetconstrI => (dsetconstrEL => (dsetconstrER => (exuE1 => (prop2setE => (emptysetE => (emptysetimpfalse => (notinemptyset => (exuE3e => (setext => (emptyI => (noeltsimpempty => (setbeta => (nonemptyE1 => (nonemptyI => (nonemptyI1 => (setadjoinIL => (emptyinunitempty => (setadjoinIR => (setadjoinE => (setadjoinOr => (setoftrueEq => (powersetI => (emptyinPowerset => (emptyInPowerset => (powersetE => (setunionI => (setunionE => (subPowSU => (exuE2 => (nonemptyImpWitness => (uniqinunit => (notinsingleton => (eqinunit => (singletonsswitch => (upairsetE => (upairsetIL => (upairsetIR => (emptyE1 => (vacuousDall => (quantDeMorgan1 => (quantDeMorgan2 => (quantDeMorgan3 => (quantDeMorgan4 => (prop2setI => (prop2set2propI => (notdexE => (notdallE => (exuI1 => (exuI3 => (exuI2 => (inCongP => (in__Cong => (exuE3u => (exu__Cong => (emptyset__Cong => (setadjoin__Cong => (powerset__Cong => (setunion__Cong => (omega__Cong => (exuEu => (descr__Cong => (dsetconstr__Cong => (subsetI1 => (eqimpsubset2 => (eqimpsubset1 => (subsetI2 => (emptysetsubset => (subsetE => (subsetE2 => (notsubsetI => (notequalI1 => (notequalI2 => (subsetRefl => (subsetTrans => (setadjoinSub => (setadjoinSub2 => (subset2powerset => (setextsub => (subsetemptysetimpeq => (powersetI1 => (powersetE1 => (inPowerset => (powersetsubset => (sepInPowerset => (sepSubset => (binunionIL => (upairset2IR => (binunionIR => (binunionEcases => (binunionE => (binunionLsub => (binunionRsub => (binintersectI => (binintersectSubset5 => (binintersectEL => (binintersectLsub => (binintersectSubset2 => (binintersectSubset3 => (binintersectER => (disjointsetsI1 => (binintersectRsub => (binintersectSubset4 => (binintersectSubset1 => (bs114d => (setminusI => (setminusEL => (setminusER => (setminusSubset2 => (setminusERneg => (setminusELneg => (setminusILneg => (setminusIRneg => (setminusLsub => (setminusSubset1 => (symdiffE => (symdiffI1 => (symdiffI2 => (symdiffIneg1 => (symdiffIneg2 => (secondinupair => (setukpairIL => (setukpairIR => (kpairiskpair => (kpairp => (singletonsubset => (singletoninpowerset => (singletoninpowunion => (upairset2E => (upairsubunion => (upairinpowunion => (ubforcartprodlem1 => (ubforcartprodlem2 => (ubforcartprodlem3 => (cartprodpairin => (cartprodmempair1 => (cartprodmempair => (setunionE2 => (setunionsingleton1 => (setunionsingleton2 => (setunionsingleton => (singletonprop => (ex1E1 => (ex1I => (ex1I2 => (singletonsuniq => (setukpairinjL1 => (kfstsingleton => (theprop => (kfstpairEq => (cartprodfstin => (setukpairinjL2 => (setukpairinjL => (setukpairinjR11 => (setukpairinjR12 => (setukpairinjR1 => (upairequniteq => (setukpairinjR2 => (setukpairinjR => (ksndsingleton => (ksndpairEq => (kpairsurjEq => (cartprodsndin => (cartprodpairmemEL => (cartprodpairmemER => (cartprodmempaircEq => (cartprodfstpairEq => (cartprodsndpairEq => (cartprodpairsurjEq => (dpsetconstrI => (dpsetconstrSub => (setOfPairsIsBReln => (dpsetconstrERa => (dpsetconstrEL1 => (dpsetconstrEL2 => (dpsetconstrER => (funcImageSingleton => (apProp => (app => (infuncsetfunc => (ap2p => (funcinfuncset => (lamProp => (lamp => (lam2p => (brelnall1 => (brelnall2 => (ex1E2 => (funcGraphProp1 => (funcGraphProp3 => (funcGraphProp2 => (funcextLem => (funcGraphProp4 => (subbreln => (eqbreln => (funcext => (funcext2 => (ap2apEq1 => (ap2apEq2 => (beta1 => (eta1 => (lam2lamEq => (beta2 => (eta2 => (iffalseProp1 => (iffalseProp2 => (iftrueProp1 => (iftrueProp2 => (ifSingleton => (ifp => (theeq => (iftrue => (iffalse => (iftrueorfalse => ! [X3,X11] : (((in @ X11) @ (powerset @ X3)) => ! [X16] : (((in @ X16) @ (powerset @ X3)) => ((in @ ((binintersect @ X11) @ X16)) @ (powerset @ X3)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) [negated conjecture 231] 9.89/10.05 233. ($false != $true) (TD) [fool axiom] 9.89/10.05 234. ~(setextAx => (emptysetAx => (setadjoinAx => (powersetAx => (setunionAx => (omega0Ax => (omegaSAx => (omegaIndAx => (replAx => (foundationAx => (wellorderingAx => (descrp => (dsetconstrI => (dsetconstrEL => (dsetconstrER => (exuE1 => (prop2setE => (emptysetE => (emptysetimpfalse => (notinemptyset => (exuE3e => (setext => (emptyI => (noeltsimpempty => (setbeta => (nonemptyE1 => (nonemptyI => (nonemptyI1 => (setadjoinIL => (emptyinunitempty => (setadjoinIR => (setadjoinE => (setadjoinOr => (setoftrueEq => (powersetI => (emptyinPowerset => (emptyInPowerset => (powersetE => (setunionI => (setunionE => (subPowSU => (exuE2 => (nonemptyImpWitness => (uniqinunit => (notinsingleton => (eqinunit => (singletonsswitch => (upairsetE => (upairsetIL => (upairsetIR => (emptyE1 => (vacuousDall => (quantDeMorgan1 => (quantDeMorgan2 => (quantDeMorgan3 => (quantDeMorgan4 => (prop2setI => (prop2set2propI => (notdexE => (notdallE => (exuI1 => (exuI3 => (exuI2 => (inCongP => (in__Cong => (exuE3u => (exu__Cong => (emptyset__Cong => (setadjoin__Cong => (powerset__Cong => (setunion__Cong => (omega__Cong => (exuEu => (descr__Cong => (dsetconstr__Cong => (subsetI1 => (eqimpsubset2 => (eqimpsubset1 => (subsetI2 => (emptysetsubset => (subsetE => (subsetE2 => (notsubsetI => (notequalI1 => (notequalI2 => (subsetRefl => (subsetTrans => (setadjoinSub => (setadjoinSub2 => (subset2powerset => (setextsub => (subsetemptysetimpeq => (powersetI1 => (powersetE1 => (inPowerset => (powersetsubset => (sepInPowerset => (sepSubset => (binunionIL => (upairset2IR => (binunionIR => (binunionEcases => (binunionE => (binunionLsub => (binunionRsub => (binintersectI => (binintersectSubset5 => (binintersectEL => (binintersectLsub => (binintersectSubset2 => (binintersectSubset3 => (binintersectER => (disjointsetsI1 => (binintersectRsub => (binintersectSubset4 => (binintersectSubset1 => (bs114d => (setminusI => (setminusEL => (setminusER => (setminusSubset2 => (setminusERneg => (setminusELneg => (setminusILneg => (setminusIRneg => (setminusLsub => (setminusSubset1 => (symdiffE => (symdiffI1 => (symdiffI2 => (symdiffIneg1 => (symdiffIneg2 => (secondinupair => (setukpairIL => (setukpairIR => (kpairiskpair => (kpairp => (singletonsubset => (singletoninpowerset => (singletoninpowunion => (upairset2E => (upairsubunion => (upairinpowunion => (ubforcartprodlem1 => (ubforcartprodlem2 => (ubforcartprodlem3 => (cartprodpairin => (cartprodmempair1 => (cartprodmempair => (setunionE2 => (setunionsingleton1 => (setunionsingleton2 => (setunionsingleton => (singletonprop => (ex1E1 => (ex1I => (ex1I2 => (singletonsuniq => (setukpairinjL1 => (kfstsingleton => (theprop => (kfstpairEq => (cartprodfstin => (setukpairinjL2 => (setukpairinjL => (setukpairinjR11 => (setukpairinjR12 => (setukpairinjR1 => (upairequniteq => (setukpairinjR2 => (setukpairinjR => (ksndsingleton => (ksndpairEq => (kpairsurjEq => (cartprodsndin => (cartprodpairmemEL => (cartprodpairmemER => (cartprodmempaircEq => (cartprodfstpairEq => (cartprodsndpairEq => (cartprodpairsurjEq => (dpsetconstrI => (dpsetconstrSub => (setOfPairsIsBReln => (dpsetconstrERa => (dpsetconstrEL1 => (dpsetconstrEL2 => (dpsetconstrER => (funcImageSingleton => (apProp => (app => (infuncsetfunc => (ap2p => (funcinfuncset => (lamProp => (lamp => (lam2p => (brelnall1 => (brelnall2 => (ex1E2 => (funcGraphProp1 => (funcGraphProp3 => (funcGraphProp2 => (funcextLem => (funcGraphProp4 => (subbreln => (eqbreln => (funcext => (funcext2 => (ap2apEq1 => (ap2apEq2 => (beta1 => (eta1 => (lam2lamEq => (beta2 => (eta2 => (iffalseProp1 => (iffalseProp2 => (iftrueProp1 => (iftrueProp2 => (ifSingleton => (ifp => (theeq => (iftrue => (iffalse => (iftrueorfalse => ! [X0,X1] : (((in @ X1) @ (powerset @ X0)) => ! [X2] : (((in @ X2) @ (powerset @ X0)) => ((in @ ((binintersect @ X1) @ X2)) @ (powerset @ X0)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) [rectify 232] 9.89/10.05 235. ~((setextAx = $true) => ((emptysetAx = $true) => ((setadjoinAx = $true) => ((powersetAx = $true) => ((setunionAx = $true) => ((omega0Ax = $true) => ((omegaSAx = $true) => ((omegaIndAx = $true) => ((replAx = $true) => ((foundationAx = $true) => ((wellorderingAx = $true) => ((descrp = $true) => ((dsetconstrI = $true) => ((dsetconstrEL = $true) => ((dsetconstrER = $true) => ((exuE1 = $true) => ((prop2setE = $true) => ((emptysetE = $true) => ((emptysetimpfalse = $true) => ((notinemptyset = $true) => ((exuE3e = $true) => ((setext = $true) => ((emptyI = $true) => ((noeltsimpempty = $true) => ((setbeta = $true) => ((nonemptyE1 = $true) => ((nonemptyI = $true) => ((nonemptyI1 = $true) => ((setadjoinIL = $true) => ((emptyinunitempty = $true) => ((setadjoinIR = $true) => ((setadjoinE = $true) => ((setadjoinOr = $true) => ((setoftrueEq = $true) => ((powersetI = $true) => ((emptyinPowerset = $true) => ((emptyInPowerset = $true) => ((powersetE = $true) => ((setunionI = $true) => ((setunionE = $true) => ((subPowSU = $true) => ((exuE2 = $true) => ((nonemptyImpWitness = $true) => ((uniqinunit = $true) => ((notinsingleton = $true) => ((eqinunit = $true) => ((singletonsswitch = $true) => ((upairsetE = $true) => ((upairsetIL = $true) => ((upairsetIR = $true) => ((emptyE1 = $true) => ((vacuousDall = $true) => ((quantDeMorgan1 = $true) => ((quantDeMorgan2 = $true) => ((quantDeMorgan3 = $true) => ((quantDeMorgan4 = $true) => ((prop2setI = $true) => ((prop2set2propI = $true) => ((notdexE = $true) => ((notdallE = $true) => ((exuI1 = $true) => ((exuI3 = $true) => ((exuI2 = $true) => ((inCongP = $true) => ((in__Cong = $true) => ((exuE3u = $true) => ((exu__Cong = $true) => ((emptyset__Cong = $true) => ((setadjoin__Cong = $true) => ((powerset__Cong = $true) => ((setunion__Cong = $true) => ((omega__Cong = $true) => ((exuEu = $true) => ((descr__Cong = $true) => ((dsetconstr__Cong = $true) => ((subsetI1 = $true) => ((eqimpsubset2 = $true) => ((eqimpsubset1 = $true) => ((subsetI2 = $true) => ((emptysetsubset = $true) => ((subsetE = $true) => ((subsetE2 = $true) => ((notsubsetI = $true) => ((notequalI1 = $true) => ((notequalI2 = $true) => ((subsetRefl = $true) => ((subsetTrans = $true) => ((setadjoinSub = $true) => ((setadjoinSub2 = $true) => ((subset2powerset = $true) => ((setextsub = $true) => ((subsetemptysetimpeq = $true) => ((powersetI1 = $true) => ((powersetE1 = $true) => ((inPowerset = $true) => ((powersetsubset = $true) => ((sepInPowerset = $true) => ((sepSubset = $true) => ((binunionIL = $true) => ((upairset2IR = $true) => ((binunionIR = $true) => ((binunionEcases = $true) => ((binunionE = $true) => ((binunionLsub = $true) => ((binunionRsub = $true) => ((binintersectI = $true) => ((binintersectSubset5 = $true) => ((binintersectEL = $true) => ((binintersectLsub = $true) => ((binintersectSubset2 = $true) => ((binintersectSubset3 = $true) => ((binintersectER = $true) => ((disjointsetsI1 = $true) => ((binintersectRsub = $true) => ((binintersectSubset4 = $true) => ((binintersectSubset1 = $true) => ((bs114d = $true) => ((setminusI = $true) => ((setminusEL = $true) => ((setminusER = $true) => ((setminusSubset2 = $true) => ((setminusERneg = $true) => ((setminusELneg = $true) => ((setminusILneg = $true) => ((setminusIRneg = $true) => ((setminusLsub = $true) => ((setminusSubset1 = $true) => ((symdiffE = $true) => ((symdiffI1 = $true) => ((symdiffI2 = $true) => ((symdiffIneg1 = $true) => ((symdiffIneg2 = $true) => ((secondinupair = $true) => ((setukpairIL = $true) => ((setukpairIR = $true) => ((kpairiskpair = $true) => ((kpairp = $true) => ((singletonsubset = $true) => ((singletoninpowerset = $true) => ((singletoninpowunion = $true) => ((upairset2E = $true) => ((upairsubunion = $true) => ((upairinpowunion = $true) => ((ubforcartprodlem1 = $true) => ((ubforcartprodlem2 = $true) => ((ubforcartprodlem3 = $true) => ((cartprodpairin = $true) => ((cartprodmempair1 = $true) => ((cartprodmempair = $true) => ((setunionE2 = $true) => ((setunionsingleton1 = $true) => ((setunionsingleton2 = $true) => ((setunionsingleton = $true) => ((singletonprop = $true) => ((ex1E1 = $true) => ((ex1I = $true) => ((ex1I2 = $true) => ((singletonsuniq = $true) => ((setukpairinjL1 = $true) => ((kfstsingleton = $true) => ((theprop = $true) => ((kfstpairEq = $true) => ((cartprodfstin = $true) => ((setukpairinjL2 = $true) => ((setukpairinjL = $true) => ((setukpairinjR11 = $true) => ((setukpairinjR12 = $true) => ((setukpairinjR1 = $true) => ((upairequniteq = $true) => ((setukpairinjR2 = $true) => ((setukpairinjR = $true) => ((ksndsingleton = $true) => ((ksndpairEq = $true) => ((kpairsurjEq = $true) => ((cartprodsndin = $true) => ((cartprodpairmemEL = $true) => ((cartprodpairmemER = $true) => ((cartprodmempaircEq = $true) => ((cartprodfstpairEq = $true) => ((cartprodsndpairEq = $true) => ((cartprodpairsurjEq = $true) => ((dpsetconstrI = $true) => ((dpsetconstrSub = $true) => ((setOfPairsIsBReln = $true) => ((dpsetconstrERa = $true) => ((dpsetconstrEL1 = $true) => ((dpsetconstrEL2 = $true) => ((dpsetconstrER = $true) => ((funcImageSingleton = $true) => ((apProp = $true) => ((app = $true) => ((infuncsetfunc = $true) => ((ap2p = $true) => ((funcinfuncset = $true) => ((lamProp = $true) => ((lamp = $true) => ((lam2p = $true) => ((brelnall1 = $true) => ((brelnall2 = $true) => ((ex1E2 = $true) => ((funcGraphProp1 = $true) => ((funcGraphProp3 = $true) => ((funcGraphProp2 = $true) => ((funcextLem = $true) => ((funcGraphProp4 = $true) => ((subbreln = $true) => ((eqbreln = $true) => ((funcext = $true) => ((funcext2 = $true) => ((ap2apEq1 = $true) => ((ap2apEq2 = $true) => ((beta1 = $true) => ((eta1 = $true) => ((lam2lamEq = $true) => ((beta2 = $true) => ((eta2 = $true) => ((iffalseProp1 = $true) => ((iffalseProp2 = $true) => ((iftrueProp1 = $true) => ((iftrueProp2 = $true) => ((ifSingleton = $true) => ((ifp = $true) => ((theeq = $true) => ((iftrue = $true) => ((iffalse = $true) => ((iftrueorfalse = $true) => ! [X0,X1] : (($true = in @ X1 @ (powerset @ X0)) => ! [X2] : (($true = in @ X2 @ (powerset @ X0)) => ($true = in @ (binintersect @ X1 @ X2) @ (powerset @ X0)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) [fool elimination 234] 9.89/10.05 406. (subset2powerset = ! [X0,X1] : (((subset @ X0) @ X1) => ((in @ X0) @ (powerset @ X1)))) [rectify 92] 9.89/10.05 407. (subset2powerset = $true) <=> ! [X0,X1] : (($true = subset @ X0 @ X1) => ($true = in @ X0 @ (powerset @ X1))) [fool elimination 406] 9.89/10.05 424. (powersetE1 = ! [X0,X1] : (((in @ X1) @ (powerset @ X0)) => ((subset @ X1) @ X0))) [rectify 96] 9.89/10.05 425. (powersetE1 = $true) <=> ! [X0,X1] : (($true = in @ X1 @ (powerset @ X0)) => ($true = subset @ X1 @ X0)) [fool elimination 424] 9.89/10.05 446. (binintersectLsub = ! [X0,X1] : ((subset @ ((binintersect @ X0) @ X1)) @ X0)) [rectify 111] 9.89/10.05 447. (binintersectLsub = $true) <=> ! [X0,X1] : ($true = subset @ (binintersect @ X0 @ X1) @ X0) [fool elimination 446] 9.89/10.05 496. (subsetTrans = ! [X0,X1,X2] : (((subset @ X0) @ X1) => (((subset @ X1) @ X2) => ((subset @ X0) @ X2)))) [rectify 89] 9.89/10.05 497. (subsetTrans = $true) <=> ! [X0,X1,X2] : (($true = subset @ X0 @ X1) => (($true = subset @ X1 @ X2) => ($true = subset @ X0 @ X2))) [fool elimination 496] 9.89/10.05 762. (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((? [X0,X1] : (? [X2] : (($true != in @ (binintersect @ X1 @ X2) @ (powerset @ X0)) & ($true = in @ X2 @ (powerset @ X0))) & ($true = in @ X1 @ (powerset @ X0))) & (iftrueorfalse = $true)) & (iffalse = $true)) & (iftrue = $true)) & (theeq = $true)) & (ifp = $true)) & (ifSingleton = $true)) & (iftrueProp2 = $true)) & (iftrueProp1 = $true)) & (iffalseProp2 = $true)) & (iffalseProp1 = $true)) & (eta2 = $true)) & (beta2 = $true)) & (lam2lamEq = $true)) & (eta1 = $true)) & (beta1 = $true)) & (ap2apEq2 = $true)) & (ap2apEq1 = $true)) & (funcext2 = $true)) & (funcext = $true)) & (eqbreln = $true)) & (subbreln = $true)) & (funcGraphProp4 = $true)) & (funcextLem = $true)) & (funcGraphProp2 = $true)) & (funcGraphProp3 = $true)) & (funcGraphProp1 = $true)) & (ex1E2 = $true)) & (brelnall2 = $true)) & (brelnall1 = $true)) & (lam2p = $true)) & (lamp = $true)) & (lamProp = $true)) & (funcinfuncset = $true)) & (ap2p = $true)) & (infuncsetfunc = $true)) & (app = $true)) & (apProp = $true)) & (funcImageSingleton = $true)) & (dpsetconstrER = $true)) & (dpsetconstrEL2 = $true)) & (dpsetconstrEL1 = $true)) & (dpsetconstrERa = $true)) & (setOfPairsIsBReln = $true)) & (dpsetconstrSub = $true)) & (dpsetconstrI = $true)) & (cartprodpairsurjEq = $true)) & (cartprodsndpairEq = $true)) & (cartprodfstpairEq = $true)) & (cartprodmempaircEq = $true)) & (cartprodpairmemER = $true)) & (cartprodpairmemEL = $true)) & (cartprodsndin = $true)) & (kpairsurjEq = $true)) & (ksndpairEq = $true)) & (ksndsingleton = $true)) & (setukpairinjR = $true)) & (setukpairinjR2 = $true)) & (upairequniteq = $true)) & (setukpairinjR1 = $true)) & (setukpairinjR12 = $true)) & (setukpairinjR11 = $true)) & (setukpairinjL = $true)) & (setukpairinjL2 = $true)) & (cartprodfstin = $true)) & (kfstpairEq = $true)) & (theprop = $true)) & (kfstsingleton = $true)) & (setukpairinjL1 = $true)) & (singletonsuniq = $true)) & (ex1I2 = $true)) & (ex1I = $true)) & (ex1E1 = $true)) & (singletonprop = $true)) & (setunionsingleton = $true)) & (setunionsingleton2 = $true)) & (setunionsingleton1 = $true)) & (setunionE2 = $true)) & (cartprodmempair = $true)) & (cartprodmempair1 = $true)) & (cartprodpairin = $true)) & (ubforcartprodlem3 = $true)) & (ubforcartprodlem2 = $true)) & (ubforcartprodlem1 = $true)) & (upairinpowunion = $true)) & (upairsubunion = $true)) & (upairset2E = $true)) & (singletoninpowunion = $true)) & (singletoninpowerset = $true)) & (singletonsubset = $true)) & (kpairp = $true)) & (kpairiskpair = $true)) & (setukpairIR = $true)) & (setukpairIL = $true)) & (secondinupair = $true)) & (symdiffIneg2 = $true)) & (symdiffIneg1 = $true)) & (symdiffI2 = $true)) & (symdiffI1 = $true)) & (symdiffE = $true)) & (setminusSubset1 = $true)) & (setminusLsub = $true)) & (setminusIRneg = $true)) & (setminusILneg = $true)) & (setminusELneg = $true)) & (setminusERneg = $true)) & (setminusSubset2 = $true)) & (setminusER = $true)) & (setminusEL = $true)) & (setminusI = $true)) & (bs114d = $true)) & (binintersectSubset1 = $true)) & (binintersectSubset4 = $true)) & (binintersectRsub = $true)) & (disjointsetsI1 = $true)) & (binintersectER = $true)) & (binintersectSubset3 = $true)) & (binintersectSubset2 = $true)) & (binintersectLsub = $true)) & (binintersectEL = $true)) & (binintersectSubset5 = $true)) & (binintersectI = $true)) & (binunionRsub = $true)) & (binunionLsub = $true)) & (binunionE = $true)) & (binunionEcases = $true)) & (binunionIR = $true)) & (upairset2IR = $true)) & (binunionIL = $true)) & (sepSubset = $true)) & (sepInPowerset = $true)) & (powersetsubset = $true)) & (inPowerset = $true)) & (powersetE1 = $true)) & (powersetI1 = $true)) & (subsetemptysetimpeq = $true)) & (setextsub = $true)) & (subset2powerset = $true)) & (setadjoinSub2 = $true)) & (setadjoinSub = $true)) & (subsetTrans = $true)) & (subsetRefl = $true)) & (notequalI2 = $true)) & (notequalI1 = $true)) & (notsubsetI = $true)) & (subsetE2 = $true)) & (subsetE = $true)) & (emptysetsubset = $true)) & (subsetI2 = $true)) & (eqimpsubset1 = $true)) & (eqimpsubset2 = $true)) & (subsetI1 = $true)) & (dsetconstr__Cong = $true)) & (descr__Cong = $true)) & (exuEu = $true)) & (omega__Cong = $true)) & (setunion__Cong = $true)) & (powerset__Cong = $true)) & (setadjoin__Cong = $true)) & (emptyset__Cong = $true)) & (exu__Cong = $true)) & (exuE3u = $true)) & (in__Cong = $true)) & (inCongP = $true)) & (exuI2 = $true)) & (exuI3 = $true)) & (exuI1 = $true)) & (notdallE = $true)) & (notdexE = $true)) & (prop2set2propI = $true)) & (prop2setI = $true)) & (quantDeMorgan4 = $true)) & (quantDeMorgan3 = $true)) & (quantDeMorgan2 = $true)) & (quantDeMorgan1 = $true)) & (vacuousDall = $true)) & (emptyE1 = $true)) & (upairsetIR = $true)) & (upairsetIL = $true)) & (upairsetE = $true)) & (singletonsswitch = $true)) & (eqinunit = $true)) & (notinsingleton = $true)) & (uniqinunit = $true)) & (nonemptyImpWitness = $true)) & (exuE2 = $true)) & (subPowSU = $true)) & (setunionE = $true)) & (setunionI = $true)) & (powersetE = $true)) & (emptyInPowerset = $true)) & (emptyinPowerset = $true)) & (powersetI = $true)) & (setoftrueEq = $true)) & (setadjoinOr = $true)) & (setadjoinE = $true)) & (setadjoinIR = $true)) & (emptyinunitempty = $true)) & (setadjoinIL = $true)) & (nonemptyI1 = $true)) & (nonemptyI = $true)) & (nonemptyE1 = $true)) & (setbeta = $true)) & (noeltsimpempty = $true)) & (emptyI = $true)) & (setext = $true)) & (exuE3e = $true)) & (notinemptyset = $true)) & (emptysetimpfalse = $true)) & (emptysetE = $true)) & (prop2setE = $true)) & (exuE1 = $true)) & (dsetconstrER = $true)) & (dsetconstrEL = $true)) & (dsetconstrI = $true)) & (descrp = $true)) & (wellorderingAx = $true)) & (foundationAx = $true)) & (replAx = $true)) & (omegaIndAx = $true)) & (omegaSAx = $true)) & (omega0Ax = $true)) & (setunionAx = $true)) & (powersetAx = $true)) & (setadjoinAx = $true)) & (emptysetAx = $true)) & (setextAx = $true) [ennf transformation 235] 9.89/10.05 763. ? [X0,X1] : (? [X2] : (($true != in @ (binintersect @ X1 @ X2) @ (powerset @ X0)) & ($true = in @ X2 @ (powerset @ X0))) & ($true = in @ X1 @ (powerset @ X0))) & (iftrueorfalse = $true) & (iffalse = $true) & (iftrue = $true) & (theeq = $true) & (ifp = $true) & (ifSingleton = $true) & (iftrueProp2 = $true) & (iftrueProp1 = $true) & (iffalseProp2 = $true) & (iffalseProp1 = $true) & (eta2 = $true) & (beta2 = $true) & (lam2lamEq = $true) & (eta1 = $true) & (beta1 = $true) & (ap2apEq2 = $true) & (ap2apEq1 = $true) & (funcext2 = $true) & (funcext = $true) & (eqbreln = $true) & (subbreln = $true) & (funcGraphProp4 = $true) & (funcextLem = $true) & (funcGraphProp2 = $true) & (funcGraphProp3 = $true) & (funcGraphProp1 = $true) & (ex1E2 = $true) & (brelnall2 = $true) & (brelnall1 = $true) & (lam2p = $true) & (lamp = $true) & (lamProp = $true) & (funcinfuncset = $true) & (ap2p = $true) & (infuncsetfunc = $true) & (app = $true) & (apProp = $true) & (funcImageSingleton = $true) & (dpsetconstrER = $true) & (dpsetconstrEL2 = $true) & (dpsetconstrEL1 = $true) & (dpsetconstrERa = $true) & (setOfPairsIsBReln = $true) & (dpsetconstrSub = $true) & (dpsetconstrI = $true) & (cartprodpairsurjEq = $true) & (cartprodsndpairEq = $true) & (cartprodfstpairEq = $true) & (cartprodmempaircEq = $true) & (cartprodpairmemER = $true) & (cartprodpairmemEL = $true) & (cartprodsndin = $true) & (kpairsurjEq = $true) & (ksndpairEq = $true) & (ksndsingleton = $true) & (setukpairinjR = $true) & (setukpairinjR2 = $true) & (upairequniteq = $true) & (setukpairinjR1 = $true) & (setukpairinjR12 = $true) & (setukpairinjR11 = $true) & (setukpairinjL = $true) & (setukpairinjL2 = $true) & (cartprodfstin = $true) & (kfstpairEq = $true) & (theprop = $true) & (kfstsingleton = $true) & (setukpairinjL1 = $true) & (singletonsuniq = $true) & (ex1I2 = $true) & (ex1I = $true) & (ex1E1 = $true) & (singletonprop = $true) & (setunionsingleton = $true) & (setunionsingleton2 = $true) & (setunionsingleton1 = $true) & (setunionE2 = $true) & (cartprodmempair = $true) & (cartprodmempair1 = $true) & (cartprodpairin = $true) & (ubforcartprodlem3 = $true) & (ubforcartprodlem2 = $true) & (ubforcartprodlem1 = $true) & (upairinpowunion = $true) & (upairsubunion = $true) & (upairset2E = $true) & (singletoninpowunion = $true) & (singletoninpowerset = $true) & (singletonsubset = $true) & (kpairp = $true) & (kpairiskpair = $true) & (setukpairIR = $true) & (setukpairIL = $true) & (secondinupair = $true) & (symdiffIneg2 = $true) & (symdiffIneg1 = $true) & (symdiffI2 = $true) & (symdiffI1 = $true) & (symdiffE = $true) & (setminusSubset1 = $true) & (setminusLsub = $true) & (setminusIRneg = $true) & (setminusILneg = $true) & (setminusELneg = $true) & (setminusERneg = $true) & (setminusSubset2 = $true) & (setminusER = $true) & (setminusEL = $true) & (setminusI = $true) & (bs114d = $true) & (binintersectSubset1 = $true) & (binintersectSubset4 = $true) & (binintersectRsub = $true) & (disjointsetsI1 = $true) & (binintersectER = $true) & (binintersectSubset3 = $true) & (binintersectSubset2 = $true) & (binintersectLsub = $true) & (binintersectEL = $true) & (binintersectSubset5 = $true) & (binintersectI = $true) & (binunionRsub = $true) & (binunionLsub = $true) & (binunionE = $true) & (binunionEcases = $true) & (binunionIR = $true) & (upairset2IR = $true) & (binunionIL = $true) & (sepSubset = $true) & (sepInPowerset = $true) & (powersetsubset = $true) & (inPowerset = $true) & (powersetE1 = $true) & (powersetI1 = $true) & (subsetemptysetimpeq = $true) & (setextsub = $true) & (subset2powerset = $true) & (setadjoinSub2 = $true) & (setadjoinSub = $true) & (subsetTrans = $true) & (subsetRefl = $true) & (notequalI2 = $true) & (notequalI1 = $true) & (notsubsetI = $true) & (subsetE2 = $true) & (subsetE = $true) & (emptysetsubset = $true) & (subsetI2 = $true) & (eqimpsubset1 = $true) & (eqimpsubset2 = $true) & (subsetI1 = $true) & (dsetconstr__Cong = $true) & (descr__Cong = $true) & (exuEu = $true) & (omega__Cong = $true) & (setunion__Cong = $true) & (powerset__Cong = $true) & (setadjoin__Cong = $true) & (emptyset__Cong = $true) & (exu__Cong = $true) & (exuE3u = $true) & (in__Cong = $true) & (inCongP = $true) & (exuI2 = $true) & (exuI3 = $true) & (exuI1 = $true) & (notdallE = $true) & (notdexE = $true) & (prop2set2propI = $true) & (prop2setI = $true) & (quantDeMorgan4 = $true) & (quantDeMorgan3 = $true) & (quantDeMorgan2 = $true) & (quantDeMorgan1 = $true) & (vacuousDall = $true) & (emptyE1 = $true) & (upairsetIR = $true) & (upairsetIL = $true) & (upairsetE = $true) & (singletonsswitch = $true) & (eqinunit = $true) & (notinsingleton = $true) & (uniqinunit = $true) & (nonemptyImpWitness = $true) & (exuE2 = $true) & (subPowSU = $true) & (setunionE = $true) & (setunionI = $true) & (powersetE = $true) & (emptyInPowerset = $true) & (emptyinPowerset = $true) & (powersetI = $true) & (setoftrueEq = $true) & (setadjoinOr = $true) & (setadjoinE = $true) & (setadjoinIR = $true) & (emptyinunitempty = $true) & (setadjoinIL = $true) & (nonemptyI1 = $true) & (nonemptyI = $true) & (nonemptyE1 = $true) & (setbeta = $true) & (noeltsimpempty = $true) & (emptyI = $true) & (setext = $true) & (exuE3e = $true) & (notinemptyset = $true) & (emptysetimpfalse = $true) & (emptysetE = $true) & (prop2setE = $true) & (exuE1 = $true) & (dsetconstrER = $true) & (dsetconstrEL = $true) & (dsetconstrI = $true) & (descrp = $true) & (wellorderingAx = $true) & (foundationAx = $true) & (replAx = $true) & (omegaIndAx = $true) & (omegaSAx = $true) & (omega0Ax = $true) & (setunionAx = $true) & (powersetAx = $true) & (setadjoinAx = $true) & (emptysetAx = $true) & (setextAx = $true) [flattening 762] 9.89/10.05 846. (subset2powerset = $true) <=> ! [X0,X1] : (($true = in @ X0 @ (powerset @ X1)) | ($true != subset @ X0 @ X1)) [ennf transformation 407] 9.89/10.05 856. (powersetE1 = $true) <=> ! [X0,X1] : (($true = subset @ X1 @ X0) | ($true != in @ X1 @ (powerset @ X0))) [ennf transformation 425] 9.89/10.05 878. (subsetTrans = $true) <=> ! [X0,X1,X2] : ((($true = subset @ X0 @ X2) | ($true != subset @ X1 @ X2)) | ($true != subset @ X0 @ X1)) [ennf transformation 497] 9.89/10.05 879. (subsetTrans = $true) <=> ! [X0,X1,X2] : (($true = subset @ X0 @ X2) | ($true != subset @ X1 @ X2) | ($true != subset @ X0 @ X1)) [flattening 878] 9.89/10.05 1120. ? [X0,X1] : (? [X2] : (($true != in @ (binintersect @ X1 @ X2) @ (powerset @ X0)) & ($true = in @ X2 @ (powerset @ X0))) & ($true = in @ X1 @ (powerset @ X0))) => (? [X2] : (($true != in @ (binintersect @ sK61 @ X2) @ (powerset @ sK60)) & ($true = in @ X2 @ (powerset @ sK60))) & ($true = in @ sK61 @ (powerset @ sK60))) [choice axiom] 9.89/10.05 1121. ? [X2] : (($true != in @ (binintersect @ X1 @ X2) @ (powerset @ X0)) & ($true = in @ X2 @ (powerset @ X0))) => (($true != in @ (binintersect @ X1 @ sK62) @ (powerset @ X0)) & ($true = in @ sK62 @ (powerset @ X0))) [choice axiom] 9.89/10.05 1122. ((($true != in @ (binintersect @ sK61 @ sK62) @ (powerset @ sK60)) & ($true = in @ sK62 @ (powerset @ sK60))) & ($true = in @ sK61 @ (powerset @ sK60))) & (iftrueorfalse = $true) & (iffalse = $true) & (iftrue = $true) & (theeq = $true) & (ifp = $true) & (ifSingleton = $true) & (iftrueProp2 = $true) & (iftrueProp1 = $true) & (iffalseProp2 = $true) & (iffalseProp1 = $true) & (eta2 = $true) & (beta2 = $true) & (lam2lamEq = $true) & (eta1 = $true) & (beta1 = $true) & (ap2apEq2 = $true) & (ap2apEq1 = $true) & (funcext2 = $true) & (funcext = $true) & (eqbreln = $true) & (subbreln = $true) & (funcGraphProp4 = $true) & (funcextLem = $true) & (funcGraphProp2 = $true) & (funcGraphProp3 = $true) & (funcGraphProp1 = $true) & (ex1E2 = $true) & (brelnall2 = $true) & (brelnall1 = $true) & (lam2p = $true) & (lamp = $true) & (lamProp = $true) & (funcinfuncset = $true) & (ap2p = $true) & (infuncsetfunc = $true) & (app = $true) & (apProp = $true) & (funcImageSingleton = $true) & (dpsetconstrER = $true) & (dpsetconstrEL2 = $true) & (dpsetconstrEL1 = $true) & (dpsetconstrERa = $true) & (setOfPairsIsBReln = $true) & (dpsetconstrSub = $true) & (dpsetconstrI = $true) & (cartprodpairsurjEq = $true) & (cartprodsndpairEq = $true) & (cartprodfstpairEq = $true) & (cartprodmempaircEq = $true) & (cartprodpairmemER = $true) & (cartprodpairmemEL = $true) & (cartprodsndin = $true) & (kpairsurjEq = $true) & (ksndpairEq = $true) & (ksndsingleton = $true) & (setukpairinjR = $true) & (setukpairinjR2 = $true) & (upairequniteq = $true) & (setukpairinjR1 = $true) & (setukpairinjR12 = $true) & (setukpairinjR11 = $true) & (setukpairinjL = $true) & (setukpairinjL2 = $true) & (cartprodfstin = $true) & (kfstpairEq = $true) & (theprop = $true) & (kfstsingleton = $true) & (setukpairinjL1 = $true) & (singletonsuniq = $true) & (ex1I2 = $true) & (ex1I = $true) & (ex1E1 = $true) & (singletonprop = $true) & (setunionsingleton = $true) & (setunionsingleton2 = $true) & (setunionsingleton1 = $true) & (setunionE2 = $true) & (cartprodmempair = $true) & (cartprodmempair1 = $true) & (cartprodpairin = $true) & (ubforcartprodlem3 = $true) & (ubforcartprodlem2 = $true) & (ubforcartprodlem1 = $true) & (upairinpowunion = $true) & (upairsubunion = $true) & (upairset2E = $true) & (singletoninpowunion = $true) & (singletoninpowerset = $true) & (singletonsubset = $true) & (kpairp = $true) & (kpairiskpair = $true) & (setukpairIR = $true) & (setukpairIL = $true) & (secondinupair = $true) & (symdiffIneg2 = $true) & (symdiffIneg1 = $true) & (symdiffI2 = $true) & (symdiffI1 = $true) & (symdiffE = $true) & (setminusSubset1 = $true) & (setminusLsub = $true) & (setminusIRneg = $true) & (setminusILneg = $true) & (setminusELneg = $true) & (setminusERneg = $true) & (setminusSubset2 = $true) & (setminusER = $true) & (setminusEL = $true) & (setminusI = $true) & (bs114d = $true) & (binintersectSubset1 = $true) & (binintersectSubset4 = $true) & (binintersectRsub = $true) & (disjointsetsI1 = $true) & (binintersectER = $true) & (binintersectSubset3 = $true) & (binintersectSubset2 = $true) & (binintersectLsub = $true) & (binintersectEL = $true) & (binintersectSubset5 = $true) & (binintersectI = $true) & (binunionRsub = $true) & (binunionLsub = $true) & (binunionE = $true) & (binunionEcases = $true) & (binunionIR = $true) & (upairset2IR = $true) & (binunionIL = $true) & (sepSubset = $true) & (sepInPowerset = $true) & (powersetsubset = $true) & (inPowerset = $true) & (powersetE1 = $true) & (powersetI1 = $true) & (subsetemptysetimpeq = $true) & (setextsub = $true) & (subset2powerset = $true) & (setadjoinSub2 = $true) & (setadjoinSub = $true) & (subsetTrans = $true) & (subsetRefl = $true) & (notequalI2 = $true) & (notequalI1 = $true) & (notsubsetI = $true) & (subsetE2 = $true) & (subsetE = $true) & (emptysetsubset = $true) & (subsetI2 = $true) & (eqimpsubset1 = $true) & (eqimpsubset2 = $true) & (subsetI1 = $true) & (dsetconstr__Cong = $true) & (descr__Cong = $true) & (exuEu = $true) & (omega__Cong = $true) & (setunion__Cong = $true) & (powerset__Cong = $true) & (setadjoin__Cong = $true) & (emptyset__Cong = $true) & (exu__Cong = $true) & (exuE3u = $true) & (in__Cong = $true) & (inCongP = $true) & (exuI2 = $true) & (exuI3 = $true) & (exuI1 = $true) & (notdallE = $true) & (notdexE = $true) & (prop2set2propI = $true) & (prop2setI = $true) & (quantDeMorgan4 = $true) & (quantDeMorgan3 = $true) & (quantDeMorgan2 = $true) & (quantDeMorgan1 = $true) & (vacuousDall = $true) & (emptyE1 = $true) & (upairsetIR = $true) & (upairsetIL = $true) & (upairsetE = $true) & (singletonsswitch = $true) & (eqinunit = $true) & (notinsingleton = $true) & (uniqinunit = $true) & (nonemptyImpWitness = $true) & (exuE2 = $true) & (subPowSU = $true) & (setunionE = $true) & (setunionI = $true) & (powersetE = $true) & (emptyInPowerset = $true) & (emptyinPowerset = $true) & (powersetI = $true) & (setoftrueEq = $true) & (setadjoinOr = $true) & (setadjoinE = $true) & (setadjoinIR = $true) & (emptyinunitempty = $true) & (setadjoinIL = $true) & (nonemptyI1 = $true) & (nonemptyI = $true) & (nonemptyE1 = $true) & (setbeta = $true) & (noeltsimpempty = $true) & (emptyI = $true) & (setext = $true) & (exuE3e = $true) & (notinemptyset = $true) & (emptysetimpfalse = $true) & (emptysetE = $true) & (prop2setE = $true) & (exuE1 = $true) & (dsetconstrER = $true) & (dsetconstrEL = $true) & (dsetconstrI = $true) & (descrp = $true) & (wellorderingAx = $true) & (foundationAx = $true) & (replAx = $true) & (omegaIndAx = $true) & (omegaSAx = $true) & (omega0Ax = $true) & (setunionAx = $true) & (powersetAx = $true) & (setadjoinAx = $true) & (emptysetAx = $true) & (setextAx = $true) [skolemisation 763,1121,1120] 9.89/10.05 1584. ((subset2powerset = $true) | ? [X0,X1] : (($true != in @ X0 @ (powerset @ X1)) & ($true = subset @ X0 @ X1))) & (! [X0,X1] : (($true = in @ X0 @ (powerset @ X1)) | ($true != subset @ X0 @ X1)) | (subset2powerset != $true)) [nnf transformation 846] 9.89/10.05 1585. ((subset2powerset = $true) | ? [X0,X1] : (($true != in @ X0 @ (powerset @ X1)) & ($true = subset @ X0 @ X1))) & (! [X2,X3] : (($true = in @ X2 @ (powerset @ X3)) | ($true != subset @ X2 @ X3)) | (subset2powerset != $true)) [rectify 1584] 9.89/10.05 1586. ? [X0,X1] : (($true != in @ X0 @ (powerset @ X1)) & ($true = subset @ X0 @ X1)) => (($true != in @ sK284 @ (powerset @ sK285)) & ($true = subset @ sK284 @ sK285)) [choice axiom] 9.89/10.05 1587. ((subset2powerset = $true) | (($true != in @ sK284 @ (powerset @ sK285)) & ($true = subset @ sK284 @ sK285))) & (! [X2,X3] : (($true = in @ X2 @ (powerset @ X3)) | ($true != subset @ X2 @ X3)) | (subset2powerset != $true)) [skolemisation 1585,1586] 9.89/10.05 1624. ((powersetE1 = $true) | ? [X0,X1] : (($true != subset @ X1 @ X0) & ($true = in @ X1 @ (powerset @ X0)))) & (! [X0,X1] : (($true = subset @ X1 @ X0) | ($true != in @ X1 @ (powerset @ X0))) | (powersetE1 != $true)) [nnf transformation 856] 9.89/10.05 1625. ((powersetE1 = $true) | ? [X0,X1] : (($true != subset @ X1 @ X0) & ($true = in @ X1 @ (powerset @ X0)))) & (! [X2,X3] : (($true = subset @ X3 @ X2) | ($true != in @ X3 @ (powerset @ X2))) | (powersetE1 != $true)) [rectify 1624] 9.89/10.05 1626. ? [X0,X1] : (($true != subset @ X1 @ X0) & ($true = in @ X1 @ (powerset @ X0))) => (($true != subset @ sK306 @ sK305) & ($true = in @ sK306 @ (powerset @ sK305))) [choice axiom] 9.89/10.05 1627. ((powersetE1 = $true) | (($true != subset @ sK306 @ sK305) & ($true = in @ sK306 @ (powerset @ sK305)))) & (! [X2,X3] : (($true = subset @ X3 @ X2) | ($true != in @ X3 @ (powerset @ X2))) | (powersetE1 != $true)) [skolemisation 1625,1626] 9.89/10.05 1674. ((binintersectLsub = $true) | ? [X0,X1] : ($true != subset @ (binintersect @ X0 @ X1) @ X0)) & (! [X0,X1] : ($true = subset @ (binintersect @ X0 @ X1) @ X0) | (binintersectLsub != $true)) [nnf transformation 447] 9.89/10.05 1675. ((binintersectLsub = $true) | ? [X0,X1] : ($true != subset @ (binintersect @ X0 @ X1) @ X0)) & (! [X2,X3] : ($true = subset @ (binintersect @ X2 @ X3) @ X2) | (binintersectLsub != $true)) [rectify 1674] 9.89/10.05 1676. ? [X0,X1] : ($true != subset @ (binintersect @ X0 @ X1) @ X0) => ($true != subset @ (binintersect @ sK331 @ sK332) @ sK331) [choice axiom] 9.89/10.05 1677. ((binintersectLsub = $true) | ($true != subset @ (binintersect @ sK331 @ sK332) @ sK331)) & (! [X2,X3] : ($true = subset @ (binintersect @ X2 @ X3) @ X2) | (binintersectLsub != $true)) [skolemisation 1675,1676] 9.89/10.05 1784. ((subsetTrans = $true) | ? [X0,X1,X2] : (($true != subset @ X0 @ X2) & ($true = subset @ X1 @ X2) & ($true = subset @ X0 @ X1))) & (! [X0,X1,X2] : (($true = subset @ X0 @ X2) | ($true != subset @ X1 @ X2) | ($true != subset @ X0 @ X1)) | (subsetTrans != $true)) [nnf transformation 879] 9.89/10.05 1785. ((subsetTrans = $true) | ? [X0,X1,X2] : (($true != subset @ X0 @ X2) & ($true = subset @ X1 @ X2) & ($true = subset @ X0 @ X1))) & (! [X3,X4,X5] : (($true = subset @ X3 @ X5) | ($true != subset @ X4 @ X5) | ($true != subset @ X3 @ X4)) | (subsetTrans != $true)) [rectify 1784] 9.89/10.05 1786. ? [X0,X1,X2] : (($true != subset @ X0 @ X2) & ($true = subset @ X1 @ X2) & ($true = subset @ X0 @ X1)) => (($true != subset @ sK403 @ sK405) & ($true = subset @ sK404 @ sK405) & ($true = subset @ sK403 @ sK404)) [choice axiom] 9.89/10.05 1787. ((subsetTrans = $true) | (($true != subset @ sK403 @ sK405) & ($true = subset @ sK404 @ sK405) & ($true = subset @ sK403 @ sK404))) & (! [X3,X4,X5] : (($true = subset @ X3 @ X5) | ($true != subset @ X4 @ X5) | ($true != subset @ X3 @ X4)) | (subsetTrans != $true)) [skolemisation 1785,1786] 9.89/10.05 2346. (subsetTrans = $true) [cnf transformation 1122] 9.89/10.05 2349. (subset2powerset = $true) [cnf transformation 1122] 9.89/10.05 2353. (powersetE1 = $true) [cnf transformation 1122] 9.89/10.05 2368. (binintersectLsub = $true) [cnf transformation 1122] 9.89/10.05 2486. ($true = in @ sK61 @ (powerset @ sK60)) [cnf transformation 1122] 9.89/10.05 2488. ($true != in @ (binintersect @ sK61 @ sK62) @ (powerset @ sK60)) [cnf transformation 1122] 9.89/10.05 2883. ($true = in @ X2 @ (powerset @ X3)) | ($true != subset @ X2 @ X3) | (subset2powerset != $true) [cnf transformation 1587] 9.89/10.05 2916. ($true = subset @ X3 @ X2) | ($true != in @ X3 @ (powerset @ X2)) | (powersetE1 != $true) [cnf transformation 1627] 9.89/10.05 2953. ($true = subset @ (binintersect @ X2 @ X3) @ X2) | (binintersectLsub != $true) [cnf transformation 1677] 9.89/10.05 3033. ($true = subset @ X3 @ X5) | ($true != subset @ X4 @ X5) | ($true != subset @ X3 @ X4) | (subsetTrans != $true) [cnf transformation 1787] 9.89/10.05 3747. ($true = in @ X2 @ (powerset @ X3)) | ($true != subset @ X2 @ X3) | ($true != $true) [definition unfolding 2883,2349] 9.89/10.05 3774. ($true = subset @ X3 @ X2) | ($true != in @ X3 @ (powerset @ X2)) | ($true != $true) [definition unfolding 2916,2353] 9.89/10.05 3798. ($true = subset @ (binintersect @ X2 @ X3) @ X2) | ($true != $true) [definition unfolding 2953,2368] 9.89/10.05 3870. ($true = subset @ X3 @ X5) | ($true != subset @ X4 @ X5) | ($true != subset @ X3 @ X4) | ($true != $true) [definition unfolding 3033,2346] 9.89/10.05 4459. ($true != subset @ X4 @ X5) | ($true = subset @ X3 @ X5) | ($true != subset @ X3 @ X4) [trivial inequality removal 3870] 9.89/10.05 4486. ($true = subset @ (binintersect @ X2 @ X3) @ X2) [trivial inequality removal 3798] 9.89/10.05 4497. ($true != in @ X3 @ (powerset @ X2)) | ($true = subset @ X3 @ X2) [trivial inequality removal 3774] 9.89/10.05 4507. ($true != subset @ X2 @ X3) | ($true = in @ X2 @ (powerset @ X3)) [trivial inequality removal 3747] 9.89/10.05 6626. ($true != $true) | ($true = subset @ sK61 @ sK60) [superposition 4497,2486] 9.89/10.05 6644. ($true = subset @ sK61 @ sK60) [trivial inequality removal 6626] 9.89/10.05 6646. ($true != $true) | ($true = in @ X2 @ (powerset @ X3)) | ($false = subset @ X2 @ X3) [fool paramodulation 4507] 9.89/10.05 6668. ($true = in @ X2 @ (powerset @ X3)) | ($false = subset @ X2 @ X3) [trivial inequality removal 6646] 9.89/10.05 6957. ($true != $true) | ($false = subset @ (binintersect @ sK61 @ sK62) @ sK60) [superposition 2488,6668] 9.89/10.05 6958. ($false = subset @ (binintersect @ sK61 @ sK62) @ sK60) [trivial inequality removal 6957] 9.89/10.05 10567. ($true != $true) | ($true = subset @ X95 @ sK60) | ($true != subset @ X95 @ sK61) [superposition 4459,6644] 9.89/10.05 10581. ($true != subset @ X95 @ sK61) | ($true = subset @ X95 @ sK60) [trivial inequality removal 10567] 9.89/10.05 10674. ($true != $true) | ($true = subset @ (binintersect @ sK61 @ X0) @ sK60) [superposition 10581,4486] 9.89/10.05 10699. ($true = subset @ (binintersect @ sK61 @ X0) @ sK60) [trivial inequality removal 10674] 9.89/10.05 10951. ($false = $true) [superposition 10699,6958] 9.89/10.05 10978. ($false != $false) [superposition 233,10951] 9.89/10.05 10983. $false [trivial inequality removal 10978] 9.89/10.05 % SZS output end Proof for theBenchmark 9.89/10.05 % ------------------------------ 9.89/10.05 % Version: Vampire 4.2.2 (commit 9d3eacc on 2019-04-30 12:01:32 +0100) 9.89/10.05 % Termination reason: Refutation 9.89/10.05 9.89/10.05 % Memory used [KB]: 12537 9.89/10.05 % Time elapsed: 0.106 s 9.89/10.05 % ------------------------------ 9.89/10.05 % ------------------------------ 9.89/10.05 % Success in time 9.718 s 9.89/10.05 EOF